🚚 Free Worldwide Shipping on All Orders!Shop Now

Ty Beanie Babies

Figurines & Crystal

Ornaments & Seasonal

Holidays & Occasions

Recently Restocked

Price

Min

-

Max

Collections

$50 to $100$25 to $50$300 & UpAll BarbiesBOGO Ornaments$100 to $200BunniesCelebrate SpringBeanie BoosAll CrystalCats & Kittens$200 to $300Holiday Beanie BabiesBearsAngels & Praying AnimalsChristmasAll Beanie BabiesAll Items In StockSports Themed Beanie BabiesDisney

Recently Restocked

Treasure Keeper

Subscribe to our newsletter for exclusive offers, new arrivals, and style inspiration.

Shop

All Products
New Arrivals
Sale

Company

Shipping Info
FAQ
Contact Us

About

About Us
Returns
Privacy

© 2026 Treasure Keeper. All rights reserved.

Recently Restocked | Treasure Keeper

...

Ty Beanie Baby: Blessed the Praying Bear - Bon-Ton & Elder-Beerman Exclusive

$5.00

Ty Beanie Baby: Bianca the Cat - Lying Down

$15.00

Ty Beanie Baby: Amber the Cat

$13.00

Ty Beanie Baby: 2003 Holiday Teddy the Bear

$7.00

Ty Beanie Baby: 1998 Holiday Teddy the Bear

$9.00

Ty Beanie Baby: Gobbles the Turkey

$10.00

Ty Beanie Baby: Grunt the Pig

$12.00

Ty Beanie Baby: Filly the Horse

$5.00

Ty Beanie Baby: Bucky the Beaver

$7.00

$2.10

Ty Beanie Baby: Chip the Cat

$16.00

$4.80

Ty Beanie Baby: 2006 Holiday Teddy the Bear

$10.00

Ty Beanie Baby: 2006 Zodiac Dog the Dog - Asia Pacific exclusive

$25.00